Judge dismisses $10 billion Mexico lawsuit against six US gunmakers

Washington DC - A US judge on Wednesday dismissed a $10 billion lawsuit brought by the Mexican government against six gun manufacturers based in the US that sought to hold them responsible for deaths from guns trafficked into Mexico.

A criminologist shows a "Uzi" submachine gun used by local drug traffickers, at the Criminology Laboratory on May 28, 2008 in Ciudad Juarez, state of Chihuahua, north Mexico.
A criminologist shows a "Uzi" submachine gun used by local drug traffickers, at the Criminology Laboratory on May 28, 2008 in Ciudad Juarez, state of Chihuahua, north Mexico.  © AFP PHOTO/Alfredo Estrella ALFREDO ESTRELLA / AFP

Judge Dennis Saylor dismissed the suit based on a lack of jurisdiction, ruling that the connections of the gun manufacturers to the state of Massachusetts, where the suit was brought, were not substantial.

"As to those defendants, the connection of this matter to Massachusetts is gossamer-thin at best," Saylor's verdict read.

Mexico tightly controls weapons sales, making them practically impossible to obtain legally.

Mexico rejects "interventionist" US critique of popular judicial reform
Mexico Mexico rejects "interventionist" US critique of popular judicial reform

But drug-related violence involving firearms remains widespread – with more than half a million weapons trafficked into Mexico from the US annually, according to the Mexican government.

In recent years, it has filed suits in the US states of Massachusetts and Arizona seeking to hold US-based gun manufacturers and dealers responsible.

Wednesday's ruling sees the charges against gunmakers Beretta USA, Colt, Glock, Barrett, Century International, and Sturm, Ruger, and Company dismissed in Massachusetts.

Judge Saylor ruled that the six defendants against whom charges were dismissed did not have a sufficient link to Massachusetts to establish jurisdiction and that the data presented by the Mexican government in the suit relied on assumptions and did not prove a direct link.

"In short, plaintiff has been unable to muster sufficient proof to establish a sufficient relationship between the claimed injuries and the business transactions of any of the six defendants in Massachusetts," the verdict read.

The suit brought in the border state of Arizona seeks sanctions against five dealers who sold guns that were used in serious crimes in Mexico.

Cover photo: AFP PHOTO/Alfredo Estrella ALFREDO ESTRELLA / AFP

More on Mexico: