Are statewide bans on plastic bags really reducing pollution?

Statewide bans on plastic bags in the US have led to significant reductions in the number of bags found on beaches and waterways, according to a scientific analysis published Monday.

Statewide bans on plastic bags in the US have led to significant reductions in the number of bags found on beaches and waterways, according to a scientific analysis published Monday.
Statewide bans on plastic bags in the US have led to significant reductions in the number of bags found on beaches and waterways, according to a scientific analysis published Monday.  © MICHAEL M. SANTIAGO / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / GETTY IMAGES VIA AFP

The number of grocery bags collected by volunteers for Ocean Conservancy's International Coastal Cleanup (ICC) doubled during the Covid-19 pandemic, a period marked by a surge in plastic bag use and the temporary suspension of bans.

But since 2020, as the percentage of the US population covered by statewide bans has risen from 12% to 25%, there has been a 29% reduction in the number of bags collected per volunteer from 2022-23 compared to pre-pandemic levels (2013-2019).

California was the first of eleven states to pass a plastic bag ban, effective since 2015.

SpaceX set for Starship's next flight – with Trump watching
Space Travel SpaceX set for Starship's next flight – with Trump watching

"Plastic bags are well-known to be one of the most deadly types of plastic pollution in our oceans," Anja Brandon, Ocean Conservancy's director of plastics policy, told AFP.

"We were really excited to see that with the increase in percentage of Americans who are covered by a strong plastic bag ban, we see less plastic bag pollution within our ICC dataset," added Brandon, an environmental engineer who has helped draft state and national legislation on plastic pollution.

The data was drawn from the ICC, an annual international cleanup effort that has run since 1986, as well as other voluntary cleanup efforts recorded in the Clean Swell app or data sheets that contribute to Ocean Conservancy's marine litter database.

Plastic bag bans prove effective in minimizing beach pollution

Since 2020, as the percentage of the US population covered by statewide bans has risen from 12% to 25%, there has been a 29% reduction in the number of bags collected per beach-cleaning volunteer.
Since 2020, as the percentage of the US population covered by statewide bans has risen from 12% to 25%, there has been a 29% reduction in the number of bags collected per beach-cleaning volunteer.  © IMAGO / ZUMA Press Wire

Ocean Conservancy applies statistical methods to weigh the citizen-science data, accounting for variations in the volume of information gathered across different locations.

As the largest database of its kind, the ICC data informs scientists, conservationists, and policymakers. It has played a key role in shaping two California laws on plastic pollution and Florida's balloon release ban, which passed earlier this year.

Turtles and birds mistake plastic bags as jellyfish and ingest them.

"Once they're ingested, they can bunch up and coil inside the stomach or intestines on an animal," explained Brandon. This can cause blockages and leave them unable to feed, leading to starvation. It can also impact turtles' buoyancy, preventing them from swimming down.

The analysis comes ahead of the next round of UN plastic treaty talks, set to take place in Busan, South Korea, in November.

"Every year, 11 million metric tons of plastic enter our oceans – that's over a garbage truck of plastic every single minute," said Brandon.

"I think it's a great reminder that systemic challenges of plastic pollution are not going to solve themselves – we need strong, effective policy interventions, we know what those are, we have the data to support them, we just need more of them."

She encouraged people to participate in the next International Coastal Cleanup slated for September 21, not only to remove trash but to contribute to data collection efforts.

Cover photo: MICHAEL M. SANTIAGO / GETTY IMAGES NORTH AMERICA / GETTY IMAGES VIA AFP

More on Environment and Climate: